Welcome to the Rules Questions & Debate section of the CoE Forum. This is the place for players to ask their rules questions to the community.
Non-official
In this board you will find people happy to answer rules questions for you. However, keep in mind that the answers provided here are not official. The only official answers are those in a Ruling Digest posted by the Netrep or the Rules Oversight Committee.
What to do when you think the existing official answer is wrong or incomplete
Yes, this happens a lot, actually much more than we'd like to. Whenever you want to answer a question, but you know your answer is contradicting the existing official rules, please indicate that in your answer. Otherwise things can get very confusing, especially to newcomers. The Rules Oversight Committee would also appreciate if you can send us an email with the ruling that you think is wrong, and we'll look into it and make the appropriate corrections.
How to get an official answer
We have opened a new email address where you can send your rules questions. However, before sending your question, please first:
1) Read the current rules carefully.
2) Check the CRF, a document containing rulings, clarifications, and errata.
3) Check the Rules Digests to see if your question has already been answered.
4) Check the different channels where players answer rules questions (Council of Elrond forum, Discord Group, Facebook Group, BGG site, etc) Many questions are already answered there.
5) Make sure your question is based on actual situations that could happen in a game; finding impossibly weird card interactions might be fun, but the ROC has to prioritize actual problems that might arise during tournament games.
If you still can't find the answer to your question, or you need an official answer, you can send it to the ROC via this address:
meccgroc[at]gmail.com
When we receive your question, the ROC members will add it to their to-do list and do their best to find a proper answer. Whenever we have a batch of questions and answers ready to be published, we will publish them in the form of a new Digest, and that answer will be official.
Rules/FAQ for this section
The place to ask and debate all rules issues related to MECCG.
Return to “Rules Questions & Debate (unofficial)”
Jump to
- The Council of Elrond
- ↳ Council Business
- ↳ Official Rulings
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #204
- ↳ Drafts
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #203
- ↳ Drafts
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #202
- ↳ Drafts
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #201
- ↳ Drafts
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #200
- ↳ Drafts
- ↳ CoE Issued Errata 2018
- ↳ CoE Rulings Digest #114 - #125
- Gamer's Gauntlet
- ↳ Online Tournaments
- ↳ Events & Gatherings
- ↳ Lure of MECCG
- ↳ Worlds
- ↳ Everything Else
- ↳ Rules Questions & Debate (unofficial)
- ↳ Decks, Strategy, Tips, Ideas
- ↳ Learning Resources
- Main Street
- ↳ Community Projects
- ↳ Middle-earth
- ↳ GCCG
- ↳ Cardnum
- ↳ The Marketplace
- ↳ Odds, Ends & Hobbit Holes
- ↳ Global Players List
- ↳ The Ale House
- Alternate Game Formats
- ↳ Arda
- ↳ Dream Cards
- ↳ News, Issues, Questions
- ↳ DC Rules, Rulings & Errata
- ↳ Dreamcard Decks
- ↳ DC Challenge Decks
- ↳ DC Sample Decks [Player Guides]
- ↳ DC versions of Challenge Decks
- ↳ Avatarless
- ↳ Atani-lords
- ↳ Balrogs
- ↳ Dragon-lords
- ↳ Dwarf-lords
- ↳ Elf-lords
- ↳ Fallen-wizards
- ↳ Ringwraiths
- ↳ Sauron
- ↳ Wizards
- ↳ Files, Docs, Goodies
- ↳ FATE
- ↳ Showcase
- ↳ Development
- ↳ Scenario Games
- ↳ Cool Play
- ↳ Dragon Hunt
- ↳ Hamburger Scenario
- ↳ White Mithril
- ↳ Solitaire Games
- National Communities
- ↳ Canadian MECCG Community
- ↳ Dutch MECCG Community
- ↳ Finnish MECCG Community
- ↳ French MECCG Community
- ↳ Présentez-vous (Introduce Yourself)
- ↳ Evénements et Tournois (Events and Tournaments)
- ↳ Règles, Aides de jeu, et Formats de jeu (Rules, Playing Aids and Game Formats)
- ↳ Règles (Rules)
- ↳ Aides de jeu (Playing Aids)
- ↳ Formats de jeu (Game Formats)
- ↳ Les cartes en Français (French cards)
- ↳ Le Jeu en Ligne avec GCCG (Playing Online with GCCG)
- ↳ Divers (General)
- ↳ German MECCG Community
- ↳ Italian MECCG Community
- ↳ USA MECCG Community
- The Archives
- ↳ The Archives
- ↳ Archived Forums
- ↳ Alternate Game Formats - Challenge Decks
- ↳ Intermediate Challenge Deck Showcase
- ↳ ICD Development
- ↳ Lost Challenge Decks
- ↳ Alternate Game Formats - Virtual Cards
- ↳ Showcase
- ↳ Development
- ↳ Bugs & Requests
- ↳ Council Business - Agenda Items
- ↳ Council Business - Worlds
- ↳ Worlds 2011 Discussion Forum
- ↳ Worlds 2008 Discussion Forum
- ↳ Worlds 2007 Discussion Forum
- ↳ Worlds 2006 Discussion Forum
- ↳ Newsletter - Preparation
- ↳ Newsletter - Showcase
- ↳ Rules and Rulings - JCP Discussion
- ↳ Rules and Rulings - NetRep Discussion Forum
- ↳ Misc Topics - Council of Elrond section
- ↳ Misc Topics - Other sections
- ↳ NetRep's Corner - Official Rulings
- ↳ Council Business
- ↳ Active Agenda Items
- ↳ Completed Agenda Items
- ↳ Feedback, Site Suggestions & Bug Reports
- ↳ General Feedback
- ↳ New Report / Request
- ↳ Resolved Reports / Requests
- ↳ Discarded
- ↳ CoE Rules & Errata Community Proposals
- ↳ 2019 Annual Rules Vote - Submissions
- ↳ 2018 Annual Rules Vote
- ↳ 2018 Annual Rules Vote - Submissions