No matter how many times someone will say that 1+3=5, it will not become a true.
No matter what authority would say that a changing of value against which a roll is made affects the roll, it will not become a true.
No matter how many times someone will say that 1+3=5, it will not become a true.
Well, it feels like you are at least half way there. What you mean by "effect is on" in place of "effect is played on" is your own business.
To (re-)summarize:
To each their own. I double checked my posts... the only thing I directly implied that you were making up (in this thread at least) is your restriction against playing items during an attack that occurs when items could normally be played, which you still haven't explained. But it seemed like you originally meant to say something else.
I wish I could agree. Deliberate disregard for ICE rules/rulings: CoE ARV 2018 #35a; CoE ARV 2018 #8. (or maybe your player guides/companions care to comment?)
Except that the publication statement is just confirmation of the CRF statement on Body Checks and they were literally written by the same person.Theo wrote: ↑Tue Jan 28, 2020 4:22 amTo (re-)summarize:
1) Your reference is from a publication that is not recognized as a rules source by CoE, even if it is recognized as a rules source by you personally.
2) Even if your reference was recognized by the CoE, it would be overruled by the literal wording of CRF 15. The literal wording of CRF is generally interpretable/enforceable; opinions about what the CRF does not literally say are not.
3) Even if your reference was recognized by the CoE, it would be overruled by CoE #55, which is presumably recognized by CoE (since it is CoE's own ruling) even if not by you personally.
When would there be a body check during a point at which items are playable?
What is the point of even saying this? If the CoE explicitly overruled an ICE ruling that is different from the CoE or the players not knowing the ICE rules. CoE 1 explicitly overrules the ICE ruling. I haven't heard of this issue coming up locally or online.Theo wrote: ↑Tue Jan 28, 2020 5:17 amI wish I could agree. Deliberate disregard for ICE rules/rulings: CoE ARV 2018 #35a; CoE ARV 2018 #8. (or maybe your player guides/companions care to comment?)
For better or worse, intent does not equate to law.