Lots to comment on here... And great to see so much input!
First of all, "a creature or agent attack that is detainment can never be defeated (LE Rules)." My Play and Examples File is good for this kind of stuff.
But the thing is, since this Nature's Revenge (former DuT) says that a character can tap to cancel an attack, he thereby automatically makes it impossible to play the other AP's keyed to single wilderness, in case of Huorn, or to Borderland in case of Ent. Is that not strange?
Actually, I thought this made a lot of sense. It gives heroes an option to NOT incur Nature's Wrath by "not killing the trees".
Choking Shadows as a name is fine.
I agree with Thorsten that Choking Shadows must read "Discard CS if attached creature's prowess is defeated." A perpetual Ent chasing Minions is no good.
Thorsten brought up the Ent-creatures-attacking-theEnt-allies problem. Hmm! Here’s my suggestion for the card, with important changes capitalized for emphasis.
Waiting Shadow/Darkness Under Tree
Permanent-event
All Awakened Plant attacks are doubled. ONE character can tap to cancel one of these attacks. [Awakened Plants with no body have 5 body.] Any Awakened Plant creature can be played against a company that defeated an Awakened Plant attack during THE SAME movement/hazard phase.
IN ADDITION, any Awakened Plant may be played keyed to a site or region where Blackbole or an Ally playable at Wellinghall is present, unless any of those allies are in the resource player’s company. Cannot be duplicated.
The rest of the information about adjacent regions and special sites (and the Faction) is not really needed and just makes the card text clunky. I want the card to say “one character” to eliminate all confusion as to whether “A character…” means “each and every character may do this.” You guys might recall the fuss over Nameless Thing.
Also, I’m not convinced that we need the body enhancement at all. It also works against the “you killed them, now you face Nature’s wrath” idea because it’s pure luck if a company that is **trying** to kill them actually succeeds (i.e., since character prowess rolls can be supported but body checks cannot). I think the card that returns them from the MP pile is a more original way of dealing with the dead Ents problem. Unless at least two of you strongly feel that we need the body modification, let’s cut it. Also, if two of you don't like the ally text, let's cut it.
I vote for “2-3-4”, but with the modifications suggested above.
Titles: Waiting Shadow or Darkness Under Tree for attack doubling card (I'd say Waiting Shadow), Choking Shadows for chaser card, Nature's Revenge for the card that returns them from the MP pile.
Frodo