Re: Doors of Night - Effect vs Card
Posted: Thu May 03, 2018 2:11 pm
I agree that a checking for presence of Doors of Night in play is not the same as a checking whether Doors of Night leaves play.
However if there is an agreement that Doors of Night effect satisfies playability condition of WoS (even if a card Doors of Night is not in play) and there is agreement that disappearing of the effect satisfies a condition of discarding WoS, I cannot agree that discarding a card Doors of Night while Doors of Night effect remains in play satisfies a condition of discarding WoS.
In other words: if a discarding of Doors of Night card (while Doors of Night effect remains in play) is a condition of discarding WoS, then disappearing a Doors of Night effect (without discarding a Doors of Night card) is not such condition.
In such situation it is possible that The Will of Sauron and Gates of Morning are in play at the same time.
Either it is checked whether a Doors of Night card leaves a play, or it is checked whether an effect of presence a Doors of Night in play disappears.
EDIT:
Changed "Leaves a play" to "disappears" in last sentence.
However if there is an agreement that Doors of Night effect satisfies playability condition of WoS (even if a card Doors of Night is not in play) and there is agreement that disappearing of the effect satisfies a condition of discarding WoS, I cannot agree that discarding a card Doors of Night while Doors of Night effect remains in play satisfies a condition of discarding WoS.
In other words: if a discarding of Doors of Night card (while Doors of Night effect remains in play) is a condition of discarding WoS, then disappearing a Doors of Night effect (without discarding a Doors of Night card) is not such condition.
In such situation it is possible that The Will of Sauron and Gates of Morning are in play at the same time.
Either it is checked whether a Doors of Night card leaves a play, or it is checked whether an effect of presence a Doors of Night in play disappears.
EDIT:
Changed "Leaves a play" to "disappears" in last sentence.