Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2008 4:00 am
<slaps himself>
<becomes slap happy>
<slaps everyone in sight>
<becomes slap happy>
<slaps everyone in sight>
MECCG Discussion Forum
https://www.councilofelrond.org/forum/
https://www.councilofelrond.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=134&t=516
Sauron wasn't the one wandering around with an 8-character company.Ringbearer wrote:Boo!!! Cheater!!!
... which lead to the question whether viewers are allowed to tell players about "false-play". I´d say yes. Judging isnt coaching.Bandobras Took wrote:Sauron wasn't the one wandering around with an 8-character company.
It should be totally independant. Viewers should not say anything is my opinion. It is up to the players to notice false-play.Alter Tuk wrote:... which lead to the question whether viewers are allowed to tell players about "false-play". I´d say yes. Judging isnt coaching.Bandobras Took wrote:Sauron wasn't the one wandering around with an 8-character company.
I'll have a write up about my epic battle with Trossell later this week.Alter Tuk wrote:The best player of the preliminary round is Sauron with sensational 18 TP.
Everybody give a clap!
IMO that's just plain stupidity. Why should someone who's been cheating(with purpose or by accident) allowed to continue doing it? Every player's not a rules-guru.Sauron wrote: It should be totally independant. Viewers should not say anything is my opinion. It is up to the players to notice false-play.
Technically you shouldn't be viewing other games, it's considered scouting.Nknma wrote:IMO that's just plain stupidity. Why should someone who's been cheating(with purpose or by accident) allowed to continue doing it? Every player's not a rules-guru.Sauron wrote: It should be totally independant. Viewers should not say anything is my opinion. It is up to the players to notice false-play.
Other than that viewers should keep their mouths shut.
If someone plays Greed and you roll for a hobbit character that would be false-play IMHO.Tegarend wrote:Which way does "greed does not affect hobbits" go?