GCCG championshp 2011?

[Bandobras Took]

MT does indeed not work on Ren or any other tapped Nazgûl.

[zirilan]

It will work on the With-king who becomes a long-event not a short-event.

[Muad'Dib]

It will work on the With-king who becomes a long-event not a short-event.

Not really because Witch-king is long event but card doesnt stay on the table. So you have effect of long event in game but without card. All tapped Nazguls immidiately go to discard.

[marcos]

it works in response, before effect resolves.

2) Along those lines, can you respond to/cancel a
nazgul's special ability with Marvels Told?
*** You can discard a tapped Witch-King, since he becomes a long
event, otherwise no, due to timing rules.

(1) The question has arisen whether the previous understanding of the interaction of Marvels Told & Voices of Malice with The Witch-King of Angmar is correct. In light of digest 110's ruling on the interaction of nazgul events and certain event-cancelers, we are making the following ruling:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If the Witch-King is tapped in response to the play of Marvels Told or Voices of Malice, then it will resolve before MT/VoM and thus be unaffected by them. If, by contrast, MT/VoM is played in response to the tapping of the Witch-King, then MT/VoM will resolve first, and discard (and thereby cancel, since it has not resolved yet) the event.

Note that Ancient Secrets does not work in the same way because it can only target permanent events.

[marcos]

link to the official announcement: http://councilofelrond.org/forum/viewto ... f=7&t=1835