Lake Town Geezer wrote: ↑Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:32 am
There has to be a point where the intent of the card has to be taken into account.
"Galadriel makes a cc modified by -3, by -1 if in a
. Any one cc made by a character not in a
or
is automatically successful. "
Meaning (or lack of it) of word "Any" is not obvious.
Often in texts of other cards this denotes extension of normal scope. Tom Bombadil, Adûnaphel the Ringwraith can tap to cancel attack or hazard that targets not their own companies. Normally, for attacks, a character must be in company facing an attack to be able to affect the attack.
Either way, if cc to be affected is a target of an action, the cc must be specified/chosen at declaration of the action. The cc to be affected must be already declared earlier in the same chain of effects.
If cc to be affected is not a target of an action, then it is specified in other way (preferably described in text of an affecting card).
Lake Town Geezer wrote: ↑Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:32 am
A newer less evident question for me though is 'should Nenya's effects stack''?
Player can play three Nenya in a row. Each affecting (targeting?) the same or different cc. Nothing in text of Nenya prevents it and no rule forbids an affecting one cc by multiple actions.