Council of Elrond

Here are the results from the 2018 Annual Rules Vote.

#1 - YES, new errata will be issued.
#2 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#3 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#4 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#5 - YES, new clarification will be issued.
#6 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#7 - YES, new clarification and errata will be issued.
#8 - Option A, new clarification will be issued.
#9 - YES, new clarifications will be issued.
#10 - YES, new errata will be issued.
#11 - Option A, new clarifications will be issued.

#12 - This was a Status Quo item.
Council Member Votes in favor (5) - the Jabberwock, Jose-san, thorondor, Logain, Thorsten the Traveller
Council Member Votes against (3) - Vastor Peredhil, cram, Shapeshifter
* While the popular vote passed in favor of this item, the final result is failure of passage due to more than 1/3 of Council Member votes against. No new erratum will be issued.

#13 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#14 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#15 - TIE, no new clarification will be issued.
#16 - TIE, no new clarification will be issued.
#17 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#18 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#19 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#20 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#21 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#22 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#23 - YES, new erratum will be issued.

#24 - This was a Status Quo item.
Council Member Votes in favor (2) - Jose-san, Logain
Council Member Votes against (6) - the Jabberwock, Vastor Peredhil, Shapeshifter, Thorsten the Traveller, thorondor, cram
* This item failed both the popular vote and the Council Member vote. No new erratum will be issued.

#25 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#26 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#27 - YES, new clarification will be issued.
#28 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#29 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#30 - YES, new clarification will be issued.
#31 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#32 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#33 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#34 - YES, new erratum will be issued.

#35A - This was a Status Quo item.
Council Member Votes in favor (5) - the Jabberwock, Jose-san, Vastor Peredhil, Thorsten the Traveller, thorondor
Council Member Votes against (1) - Shapeshifter
Council Member Votes abstained (2) - Logain, cram
* The popular vote passed this item with a YES result and more than 1/3 of Council Members did not vote against the proposal, so this item passed and is subject to the result of 35B.

#35B - Option A, a new erratum will be issued.
#36 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#37 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#38 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#39 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#40 - YES, new erratum will be issued.
#41 - YES, new erratum will be issued.


To say that every vote counted on items #11, #15, #16, and #35B is an understatement. Thanks again to all for your participation! Please leave your feedback here: viewtopic.php?f=118&t=3440

The 2018 Annual Rules Vote forum may now be viewed by non-registered voters and guests.

I dare to say that viewing the results in full (i.e. how many persons voted on each of the topics, and how many votes there were for the winning option) would be an interesting lecture. Any plans to publish that?

kober wrote: ↑Wed Jun 27, 2018 6:02 pm I dare to say that viewing the results in full (i.e. how many persons voted on each of the topics, and how many votes there were for the winning option) would be an interesting lecture. Any plans to publish that?

You feel it is necessary for me to publish it in a single master list?

The data you request is available to everyone now if you simply click on the polling topic you are interested in. At the top it shows total votes broken down by result. The only information hidden is the specific names of those who voted on each option.

the Jabberwock wrote: ↑Wed Jun 27, 2018 7:11 pmThe data you request is available to everyone now if you simply click on the polling topic you are interested in. At the top it shows total votes broken down by result.

My request was based on tapatalk-browsing through the ballots, and said data is not visible in the app. My apologies, I should have checked via a browser. Cheers!

Hi guys,
will the new errata 2018 be already valid for worlds end of October?!

Cheers

Heiner

Smaug wrote: ↑Tue Oct 02, 2018 7:44 am Hi guys,
will the new errata 2018 be already valid for worlds end of October?!

Cheers

Heiner

Greetings Heiner,

Yes indeed, all new errata issued is valid and in effect immediately upon passage. The ROC deliberately held the ARV several months in advance of Worlds in order to allow adequate time for preparations and any needed adjustments.

I have just completed a Master Index found here for easy reference of all CoE issued errata & clarifications:
viewtopic.php?f=103&t=3541

Best,

Gavin